The Christmas Story: One Saviour, Three Witnesses
The Bible does not give us the Christmas story in a single account. It gives us three. Matthew, Luke and John each tell of Christ’s coming from a different vantage point, and each adds something the others leave out. (Mark, the fourth Gospel, begins with Jesus as a grown man, so it has no birth account.) Read together, they give us a far fuller picture than any one of them alone.
Matthew tells the story largely through Joseph’s eyes, and he writes to show that Jesus is the promised King. Again and again he pauses to point out that what happened was spoken long before by the prophets. In Matthew we meet the wise men who came to worship, the jealous King Herod, and a family forced to flee into Egypt.
Luke tells the story largely from Mary’s side. As a careful historian, he gives us the details: Caesar’s decree, the journey to Bethlehem, the manger and the shepherds in the field. Luke shows us a Saviour who came in humility and was announced first to humble people.
John tells the story from heaven’s side. He skips Bethlehem entirely and begins “In the beginning…” Where Matthew and Luke show us how Jesus came, John shows us who came: the eternal Word, the Creator of all things, who “…was made flesh, and dwelt among us…” (John 1:14).
| Matthew | Luke | John | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Told from | Joseph’s side | Mary’s side | Heaven’s side |
| Shows Jesus as | The promised King | The humble Saviour | The eternal Word, God in the flesh |
| Key moments | The angel’s message to Joseph, the wise men, Herod, the flight into Egypt | Gabriel’s visit to Mary, the manger, the shepherds and the angels | The Word with God from the beginning, the Word made flesh |
How the Accounts Fit Together
Matthew and Luke agree on the essentials. Jesus was born of a virgin named Mary, who was espoused to Joseph, a descendant of David. An angel gave Him the name Jesus before His birth. He was born in Bethlehem during the reign of Herod, and He grew up in Nazareth.
Where they differ, the accounts do not contradict each other. They fill in different parts of the story. The familiar nativity scene puts the shepherds and the wise men side by side at the manger, but they came at different times. The shepherds came the very night Jesus was born. The wise men arrived later, perhaps a year or more afterward. By then the family was living in a house, and Jesus is called a “young child” rather than a babe. John, meanwhile, adds what neither of the others could show from earth: that the Child in the manger existed before the world began.
One Story, One Saviour
Three writers, three perspectives, but one message. The King promised by the prophets, the Saviour announced to the shepherds and the eternal Word who made all things are the same Person. Isaiah saw Him coming seven centuries before Bethlehem:
“For unto us a child is born, unto us a son is given: and the government shall be upon his shoulder: and his name shall be called Wonderful, Counsellor, The mighty God, The everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace.” (Isaiah 9:6)
To read each account for yourself, start with the Gospel that draws you. You can read Matthew’s or Luke’s account straight through, explore what each one teaches, or see the Christmas story from heaven’s side in John.
